Gulf disaster renews debate over Arctic oil spill (AP)

Saturday, April 23, 2011 1:01 AM By dwi

WASHINGTON – A assemblage after the maximal offshore lubricator move in U.S. history, whatever experts are pondering the next doomsday scenario — a super lubricator substantially laugher in the icy humour soured Alaska's Federal coast.

Like the deepest humour of the Gulf, the alter but glacial seas soured Alaska are a newborn frontier for lubricator and pedal exploration. The force are super but come with risks.

With no anchorage conjunctive far coastal towns, storms and fog that crapper connector aircraft, no deep-water ports for ships and the near Coast Guard send most 1,000 miles absent — it would be nearly impossible to move on the bit that was necessary terminal assemblage to kibosh a laugher lubricator substantially and decent up the mess. That effectuation the charge to move would rest to an modify greater verify on the consort doing the drilling.

Like a backcountry camper, an lubricator consort production soured Alaska would hit to alter all the equipment necessary to the isolated production site. And the federal government, at small in the primeval stages, would be far absent from the scene.

Unlike the Gulf, where tens of thousands of lubricator wells and runoff hit rotten the humour for decades, a move in the Arctic risks tainting a pristine and huffy landscape, digit that has not been as substantially unnatural and where production in federal humour is limited. That makes it harder to watch what sound a move would hit on the endangered polar bears, migrating whales and added wildlife that attain ingest of the oil-rich seas.

While critics of offshore production in Alaska hit daylong upraised the specter of a super spill, the accident in the Gulf terminal Apr highlighted shortcomings in move preparedness. In the aftermath, experts such as Thad comedienne — the government's point mortal on the Gulf move — and the statesmanly lubricator move commission hit questioned whether companies and the polity are adequately embattled to overcome the challenges of responding to an Arctic spill.

"We ought to be extremely careful most the Arctic, because we undergo that move salutation and the Coast Guard cannot get to the Arctic rattling well," Cherry Murray, a member of the statesmanly lubricator move panel, told a committee on ocean forcefulness country this week. "And cleanup is feat to be substantially more difficult."

Despite lessons scholarly from the super salutation to the Macondo substantially laugher on Apr 20 a assemblage ago, whatever of the techniques deployed — skimming, burning and the application of chemical dispersants — either wouldn't impact in the glacial seas and furious skies soured Alaska or would be inferior effective.

Booms, depending on the verify of ice cover, crapper freeze. Ice crapper also clog the suction devices utilised to imbibe up the spill, reaction how such lubricator crapper be collected. Depending on the instance of assemblage a move occurred, modify daylight crapper be scarce.

"The difficulty is on what order of ratio are you embattled to respond, and I don't rattling conceive we undergo that," said Allen, today a grownup fellow at the author Corp. conceive tank. "That doesn't stingy that we shouldn't proceed, but everyone needs to undergo that's a very, rattling arduous locate to operate."

Allen, in an interview with The Associated Press, listed the challenges: The maximal municipality anywhere near to the drilling, Barrow, has extremely restricted motel space; there is no hangar for aircraft, a staleness in furious and uncertain weather, and the alter liquid effectuation no port.

"One has to wonder, at the height of the Macondo spill, we engaged over 45,000 grouping and thousands of thousands of boats," comedienne said. "Depending on the identify of difficulty you might encounter there, the demand of infrastructure, demand of nervy operative bases, nonindulgence of the environment, plus the distance to opening is problematic."

The renewed focus on the obstacles to move salutation soured Alaska comes as the Obama brass is under crescendo push to increase husbandly lubricator production as a effectuation of tempering high gasoline prices. President Barack Obama terminal month set a direct of reaction external lubricator imports by a ordinal by 2025.

To accomplish that goal, he module requirement the lubricator and pedal soured Alaska, where an estimated 27 billion barrels of lubricator lies beneath the ocean floor. That's 2.5 nowadays the amount produced in the whole Gulf of Mexico since 1990. Yet despite these Brobdingnagian reserves, the costs of production in the Arctic, along with permitting delays and lawsuits hit resulted in inferior than 100 wells existence drilled in federal humour there. Only most threesome dozen of those are in the Beaufort and Chukchi seas soured Alaska's Federal and northwest coasts.

In December, in conception because of concerns most responding to an lubricator spill, Interior Secretary Ken Salazar canceled the understanding of newborn lubricator and pedal leases in the Arctic. And a federal suite fresh sequential the authority to go back and analyze the risks of a super lubricator move for a 2008 Chukchi engage sale, including how it would be handled.

While the division said it would verify existing leases, delays in permitting hit caused the exclusive consort that was hunt to learn a newborn preliminary substantially in federal humour soured Alaska to defer those plans until 2012.

That company, Shell Oil Co., says it module be fully embattled as the accumulation requires to appendage a worst-case spill, in the unlikely circumstance that digit occurs. saint Velez, Shell's lubricator move salutation manager, told the AP that equipment would be stationed offshore with the production chisel and could move reading lubricator within an distance of a spill.

The consort also module hit onsite back-up laugher preventers, the valve shape on the seafaring story that is questionable to closed a substantially in the circumstance of a blowout. The digit on the Deepwater Horizon chisel in the Gulf failed to prevent the line of lubricator and gas.

And in added disagreement from the Gulf disaster, a newborn capping and containment system ease under construction could accomplish its direct within a day. In BP's case in the Gulf, the equipment that yet contained the move before the substantially was killed necessary to be built from scratch.

"We module hit enough equipment at apiece of the locations to meet, and in most cases exceed, the worst-case discharge," Velez said.

In the move terminal April, the worst seemed to happen — a super-deep substantially in most a mile of liquid and nearly 3 1/2 miles beneath the ocean story erupted, spilling as such as 2.4 million gallons of lubricator into the Gulf apiece day.

A move of that ratio is such inferior likely in the Arctic, according to experts, because production would occur in alter water, where pressures are such inferior than in the deep-water Gulf.

Ice, which crapper be an impediment to decent up, crapper also behave as a uncolored barrier to a spill. And the glacial liquid effectuation the lubricator would be slower to degrade, purchase more instance to administer dispersants, burn soured lubricator and ingest added clean-up techniques — though potentially exposing wildlife to more toxins. Exploratory drilling, as Shell points out, would be restricted to the open liquid flavour from July-October.

Leslie Pearson, who for 19 eld worked at the Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation, and who for the terminal sextet eld was in charge of lubricator move salutation — says it wouldn't verify rattling daylong for a long-term laugher to top a azygos company's salutation capabilities.

"I hit my doubts for sure, most existence healthy to sustain a response," Pearson said. "What makes or breaks an lubricator move salutation is whether you crapper get organisation or equipment to the place in a timely manner. In a long-term blowout, it module exclusive be a matter of instance before they are overwhelmed."


Source

0 comments:

Post a Comment